In our work with clients on financial stewardship and internal controls, we often see organizations—especially small businesses, nonprofits, and governmental entities—struggling to balance purchasing flexibility with risk management. Credit cards, purchase cards (p-cards), and debit cards each offer convenience for small-dollar purchases, but also carry varying levels of risk. Implementing strong internal controls is essential to prevent fraud, misuse, and compliance violations.
Below are best practices tailored to each payment method, with a focus on safeguarding your organization’s assets and ensuring accountability. Establishing clear policies and effective internal controls for each card type should be a top consideration.
Credit cards: Widely used, but not without risk
Credit cards are a common tool for operational purchases. However, without proper oversight, they can become a source of fraud and abuse.
-
Policy clarity: Define allowable and prohibited uses. For example, prohibit use for grant-funded or capital expenditures unless pre-approved, as these often require additional documentation and controls.
P-cards cards: Flexible and controllable
P-cards offer more granular control than traditional credit cards, making them a preferred option for many organizations.
Debit cards: High risk, use with caution
While debit cards provide immediate access to funds, they expose organizations to greater risk due to limited fraud protection and direct access to bank accounts. Debit card use should have robust internal controls and monitoring.
-
Incident response plan: Develop and test a response plan for potential breaches, including steps for reporting, containment, and recovery.
Note: Due to the inherent risks, debit cards are generally not recommended for business use unless absolutely necessary and tightly controlled.
Special considerations for nonprofits and governmental entities
For nonprofits and governmental organizations, internal controls are not just best practices—they are often compliance requirements. Misuse of funds, especially grant money, can lead to serious consequences, including loss of funding or legal action.
Our recommendations
Final thoughts
Choosing the right purchasing method is about more than convenience—it’s about protecting your organization’s financial integrity. We recommend reviewing your current practices and updating your policies to reflect these best practices. If you need help assessing your internal controls or designing a card policy tailored to your organization, BerryDunn can help. Our specialized nonprofit and governmental teams work with organizations throughout New England and beyond. We understand and embrace the unique challenges faced by these entities—and recognize the vital importance of putting the mission first. Learn more about our team and services.