Who this applies to: Decision-makers, team members, and management at a solar project developer.
A sale-leaseback can provide solar developers with an alternate source of financing. When structured appropriately, it can help a developer convert future tax benefits into current liquidity and redeploy that capital into its operations. However, it is critical for a developer's management team to evaluate the full economics early in the process, including how the transaction will be accounted for.
How a sale-leaseback structure works
In a typical transaction, a developer constructs and sells the project to an investor who then places the solar project into service and utilizes the available tax benefits. The investor then leases the project back to the developer. The investor receives the available tax attributes and lease income. The developer receives sale proceeds, as a return on their cost investment in the project, continues operating the project, and makes ongoing lease payments under the lease agreement. The transaction mechanics require coordination across the developer’s tax, legal, finance, and operations teams.
Why consider a sale-leaseback transaction?
Monetize tax attributes the developer may not be able to use:
Solar projects may generate investment tax credits and accelerated depreciation. If the project developer does not have sufficient taxable income to monetize those benefits efficiently, an investor with sufficient taxable income may be able to realize greater value from the credits. The sale proceeds can improve project economics and provide liquidity sooner.
Recycle capital into the development pipeline:
Renewable energy developers often need to fund several projects at once, requiring capital that traditional bank lending may not provide. Sale proceeds can be used to repay construction financing, support working capital, or fund the next group of projects. For a growing developer, that ability to recycle capital can be advantageous.
Maintain operational involvement:
A sale-leaseback is different from a complete project exit. Depending on the arrangement, the developer may continue to manage operations and maintenance, customer relationships, and power purchase agreement obligations. This can provide capital while preserving an ongoing role in a strategic asset.
Potential tax and financial reporting differences
Under US GAAP, the transfer must meet the applicable sale criteria to be accounted for as a sale. If those criteria are not met, the arrangement instead may be accounted for as a financing transaction.
Tax ownership and US GAAP ownership may differ. In most sale-leaseback transactions, the investor will be treated as the owner of the project for federal income tax purposes and therefore receives the associated tax attributes, even though the transaction may not qualify for sale accounting under US GAAP.
In those situations, the developer may continue to report the project on its US GAAP financial statements and account for the proceeds as a financing obligation. As a result, the anticipated allocation of tax benefits may be achieved while the financial reporting outcome presents a different picture.
Key sale-leaseback questions to address
A practical review should answer the following questions before transaction documents are finalized:
- What is the primary objective: tax monetization, construction debt repayment, liquidity, portfolio growth, or a combination of these objectives?
- Does the proposed transfer meet the sale criteria under US GAAP?
- What ongoing rights and obligations will the developer retain?
- How will lease payments, renewal terms, purchase options, and end-of-term provisions affect the economics?
- What is the impact on financial statement presentation, leverage measures, and covenant calculations?
- How does the structure compare with tax credit transfer, a partnership flip, or a full project sale?
- Are the tax, legal, finance, and operational analyses aligned with the final transaction terms?
Common missteps to avoid
Issues that create avoidable surprises:
- Starting the financial analysis too late: If the review begins after key terms are negotiated, management may have fewer options to address an unintended reporting outcome.
- Focusing only on proceeds: Up-front cash received is important, but so are lease obligations, retained responsibilities, and the effect on future flexibility.
- Reviewing each workstream in isolation: Tax, legal, finance, and operations should evaluate the same agreement and assumptions. A change that appears minor to one function may matter to another.
Preparing for a sale-leaseback
Before moving forward:
- Build a cross-functional transaction team.
- Identify the desired business and reporting outcomes.
- Prepare a side-by-side comparison of the available financing structures.
Complete the accounting analysis using substantially complete transaction documents and revisit the conclusion if key terms change.
There is no one-size-fits-all answer. The right structure depends on the project, the developer’s tax position, investor availability, cost of capital, reporting objectives, and long-term ownership strategy. Developer management teams that evaluate those factors together are better positioned to avoid surprises and make a decision that supports both the project and the broader business.
What to analyze before a sale-leaseback
Developers considering a sale-leaseback transaction should involve their accounting, tax, legal, and operational teams early in the evaluation process. Areas that may require analysis include:
- Lease accounting and sale-leaseback analyses
- Technical accounting for renewable energy transactions
- Financial statement audits and reviews
- Project entity reporting and consolidation matters
- Tax credit and project finance structuring considerations
- Transaction advisory, outsourced accounting, and financial reporting support
Key takeaways
- Evaluate the full economics of a solar sale-leaseback early, including its accounting, tax, financial, and operational implications.
- Determine whether the proposed transfer meets the sale criteria under US GAAP and understand how the accounting outcome may differ from the tax treatment.
- Assess ongoing lease obligations, retained responsibilities, and their potential effects on financial reporting, leverage, and flexibility.
- Compare a sale-leaseback with other financing structures, such as tax credit transfers, partnership flips, or a full project sale.
- Coordinate tax, legal, finance, and operations teams early so the analysis reflects the final transaction terms and intended outcomes.
BerryDunn can help
Our experienced team of tax and advisory professionals provides strategies and long-term plans that help businesses seeking energy-efficiency initiatives. We partner with clients at every stage, offering tax advisory, financial, and accounting services for cleantech companies involved in solar, wind, biomass, waste-to-energy, and energy-efficiency projects. Learn more about our team and services.