Local governments are at a pivotal moment. As retirements accelerate and community needs shift, traditional hiring methods are no longer enough to build resilient, diverse teams. More than half of U.S. states, including the state of Washington, have adopted policies encouraging skills-based hiring, and in states with these policies, 22 out of 25 saw their share of job postings without degree requirements increase (National Governors Association, 2024). This shift is helping governments address talent shortages and diversify their workforce. To meet today’s challenges, local governments must embrace skill-based recruitment—an approach that values practical abilities and real-world experience.
For further guidance, see the State of Washington’s Executive Order 24-04 Toolkit. While the Executive Order applies to state agencies, local governments may find these resources helpful in shaping their own skills-based hiring practices.
Why traditional hiring methods are no longer enough
In today’s public sector, workforce shortages are common, and the pace of change is relentless. New challenges in public health, infrastructure, and digital services demand skills that may not be reflected in a candidate’s formal education or years of experience. Too often, traditional hiring overlooks those who have gained expertise through nontraditional paths—military service, community leadership, or hands-on technical work.
Local governments must ask themselves: Are we missing out on talent by focusing too much on credentials? By shifting the lens to skills and competencies, agencies can tap into a broader pool of candidates, foster innovation, and ensure continuity in essential services.
The challenge of credential-focused hiring
Credential-focused hiring can unintentionally create barriers. Job postings that require specific degrees or a set number of years in a particular field may exclude candidates with relevant experience gained elsewhere. This approach also tends to favor those with uninterrupted career paths, overlooking individuals who have taken employment gaps for caregiving, education, or other reasons.
Consider the resident who has managed complex projects in a local nonprofit or led teams in a small business. They may be just as qualified as someone with a formal degree, but rigid requirements keep them out. Overreliance on credentials can also lead to homogeneous teams, limiting diversity of thought and experience—something local governments cannot afford as they strive to serve increasingly diverse communities.
Best practice: Audit your job postings. Are there degree or experience requirements that could be replaced with practical skills?
Building community talent pipelines
The solution starts with community engagement. Local governments can build robust talent pipelines by partnering with colleges, trade schools, and organizations that serve nontraditional candidates. These partnerships help align curricula with the real needs of public service, ensuring graduates are ready for the challenges ahead.
Welcoming candidates from alternative career paths—veterans, caregivers returning to work, or those switching industries—broadens the talent pool and strengthens the workforce. Outreach programs and mentorship are critical for raising awareness of local government careers and helping candidates develop the skills needed for success.
Best practice: Reach out to local schools and organizations. Launch an outreach campaign to promote public sector opportunities and offer mentorship to new candidates.
Shifting from degree requirements to demonstrated competencies
At the heart of skill-based recruitment is a focus on competencies. Local governments should define the core skills required for each role, moving away from unnecessary degree requirements. Hiring managers can be encouraged to value diverse experiences, recognizing that adaptability, problem-solving, and communication are often more important than formal credentials.
Updating job descriptions to emphasize essential and adaptive skills helps attract a wider range of applicants. Clearly distinguishing between “must-have” and “nice-to-have” requirements ensures postings are realistic and inclusive.
Best practice: Rewrite one job posting this quarter to focus on skills and competencies instead of degrees.
Rethinking resumes and screening processes
Skill-based recruitment means looking beyond degrees and job titles. Reviewers should seek evidence of practical experience—project outcomes, leadership roles, technical achievements. Removing bias is crucial: anonymizing applications and training hiring managers to recognize unconscious bias helps ensure fairness. Using objective, skill-based criteria for initial screening levels the playing field for all candidates.
Practical assessments, such as job-relevant tasks or simulations, allow agencies to evaluate problem-solving, communication, and technical skills directly. Fairness and transparency in assessment methods are essential, and candidates should be evaluated based on real-world achievements.
Best practice: Pilot a resume review process that highlights skills and anonymizes candidate information. Add a practical skills assessment to your next hiring process.
The payoff: a diverse and adaptable workforce
Skill-based recruitment offers significant benefits. By focusing on what candidates can do, local governments build teams that are more diverse, adaptable, and resilient. This approach helps fill critical gaps, fosters innovation, and ensures that public services remain responsive to changing needs.
Embracing innovative hiring practices is not just a matter of policy—it is a commitment to building a future-ready workforce. Local governments must lead by example, adopting inclusive and practical recruitment strategies that reflect the values and needs of their communities.
A call to action for local government leaders
Now is the time to review hiring practices, update job descriptions, and invest in outreach and training programs that prioritize skills over credentials. By taking these steps, local governments will open doors to a wider range of candidates, strengthen their teams, and deliver better outcomes for residents.
Building a future-ready workforce requires courage, creativity, and collaboration. By embracing skill-based recruitment, local governments can empower progress and drive public sector excellence for years to come.
Focused on inspiring organizations to transform and innovate, BerryDunn’s Local Government Practice Group can help you solve your biggest challenges for your organization as a whole and in specific areas. Our team is comprised of broadly specialized consultants and former local government employees that exclusively serve local government clients. Learn more about our services and team.